
Makebelieve Help, Old Butchers, and Figuring Out Who You Are (For Now)
1 month ago
-
Vimeo: About / Blog / Developers / Jobs / Community Guidelines / Community Forums / Help Center / Site Map / Merchandise
/ Get Vimeo

Previous Week
"We have to not make everything we do a perilous threat" is particularly resonant, but there were a lot of very solid strands in here that I'm looking forward to hearing more of your thoughts about.
I gotta go write now.
(And yes, me too; my book's definitely being about more than just how to let go of some stuff around your home & head. It's fun when the ideas get bigger, isn't it?).
Lunch again sometime soon. :)
Thank you, sir.
Also, good to see you are doing well mentally.
This reminds me of the Gruen Transfer, which Wikipedia describes as “the moment when a consumer enters a shopping mall, and, surrounded by an intentionally confusing layout, loses track of their original intentions.”
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gruen_transfer
It seems to me this concept might have a place in your book, if it hasn’t found one already. Certainly, there are clear parallels between the “scripted disorientation” present in shopping mall design and in the writing of ill-conceived ‘hack’ posts.
Love what you do.
(I had more until I deleted it and just went with the above... it sums things up nicely.)
I think I'm going to have to watch this one a few times (truth be told, I already have). There is a *lot* there to process.
You said (quite a few times, i wasn't counting) that you need to "figure out who you are".. but I would posit that the reason people spend the time "dicking" around is that, when it comes down to it, they *can't* figure it out.. if they had, they wouldn't need to dick around..
I know thats me.. I KNOW i'm dicking around, but i KEEP dicking around, because I CANT figure it out.. (and i've been trying, with your sporadic input, for quite a while)
So I would like to propose an addendum to your advice..
If you have spent way too much time figuring it out (on your own, not by following the prime numbered lists) and you *still* can't manage it, then STOP.. and _*DECIDE*_ who you are going to be.. after all, since nobody else can help you "figure".. it goes without saying that they also can't "dictate"..
So I give you permission to DECIDE who you are.. even (or more likely - especially) if what that is turns out to be diametrically opposed to what you thought you were to begin with..
(oh, and en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_stages_of_competence has a nice quote about the "fifth" stage that I think you were alluding to as your master)
cheers..
Here's my feedback to your feedback:
Unfortunately, what you describe is not possible for most people without eventually becoming an unemployed psychopath.
We can *DECIDE* who we are (in the sense I'd described), but we're also necessarily connected to lots of other people and expectations. THAT is the complicated part and it's why, in my opinion, most of the people who crave a new "system" need a new system like a hole in the head.
Viz: if you do nothing but listen to other people, you become a human xerox machine; if you listen to no one but yourself, you become an island.
The tricky part, as I should get better at saying, is that this is a never-ending process that gets tweaked in real time. Like the "wicked problem" ( bit.ly/2QA2jP ) these are challenges that we can't always understand until they're behind us.
My big point is the most obvious one in the world. We need to stay aware. And we need the lightest framework we can tolerate for reminding us to be aware. And for a lot of folks I know, that may mean discarding the comforts of systems, "tricks," and "tips" that produce a false sense of accomplishment and control. I believe that for everyone this means "deciding" = iterating that mix of open attention and inward consideration. Attention and time.
Anyway. Blah blah. Book chapter.
Thanks, Daniel. I appreciate the remarks.